Cast of Eddington (2025) – Full List of Actors

The announcement of Ari Aster’s next project, Eddington, came with a cast list that reads like a Hollywood dream team. Joaquin Phoenix, Pedro Pascal, Emma Stone, and Austin Butler lead an ensemble in this satirical neo-Western thriller set to hit theaters in July 2025. Here’s everything we know so far about the cast, the story, and why this film has already stirred up as much curiosity as controversy.

Main Cast Members: 7 · Director: Ari Aster · Release Year: 2025 · Genre: Comedy horror · Starring: Joaquin Phoenix, Pedro Pascal, Emma Stone · Rating (Rotten Tomatoes): Not yet available

The 6 key facts below outline the essentials of Eddington at a glance. Note the mix of confirmed production details and gaps that still invite speculation.

Is the movie Eddington based on a true story?

What is the real story behind Eddington?

• Eddington is a fictional film, not based on a true story. The plot is an original creation by Ari Aster (Wikipedia (public encyclopedia)).

The implication: Aster is working entirely from his own imagination, not adapting real events. That gives him creative freedom but also raises the bar for coherence in a story that some early watchers have called divisive.

How accurate is the film compared to real events?

Since the film is wholly fictional, accuracy to real events is not applicable. The town of Eddington, New Mexico, does not exist outside the movie.

Bottom line: Eddington is pure invention. Viewers looking for a true-crime adaptation will be disappointed, but fans of Aster’s original voice will find exactly what they expect.

What is the movie Eddington about?

Plot overview: the standoff in a small town

• The film follows a standoff between a small-town sheriff (Joaquin Phoenix) and mayor (Pedro Pascal). Neighbors are pitted against neighbors in a powder-keg situation (Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator)).

Key characters and their roles

• Joaquin Phoenix plays Joe Cross, the sheriff (IMDb (film database))
• Pedro Pascal plays Ted Garcia, the mayor (IMDb (film database))
• Emma Stone plays Louise Cross (IMDb (film database))
• Austin Butler plays Vernon Jefferson Peak (IMDb (film database))
• Luke Grimes plays Guy Tooley (IMDb (film database))
• Deirdre O’Connell plays Dawn Bodkin (IMDb (film database))
• Micheal Ward plays Michael Cooke (IMDb (film database))

The pattern: the cast brings together heavyweights and rising stars, but the roles remain tightly linked to a small-town conflict — a stage for intimate drama rather than spectacle.

Who are the cast members of Eddington?

Main cast: Joaquin Phoenix, Pedro Pascal, Emma Stone, and others

• Joaquin Phoenix as Joe Cross (IMDb (film database))
• Pedro Pascal as Ted Garcia (IMDb (film database))
• Emma Stone as Louise Cross (IMDb (film database))
• Austin Butler as Vernon Jefferson Peak (IMDb (film database))
• Luke Grimes as Guy Tooley (IMDb (film database))
• Deirdre O’Connell as Dawn Bodkin (IMDb (film database))
• Micheal Ward as Michael Cooke (IMDb (film database))

Supporting cast and their characters

• Amélie Hoeferle as Sarah (IMDb (film database))
• Clifton Collins Jr. as Lodge (IMDb (film database))
• William Belleau as Officer Butterfly Jimenez (IMDb (film database))
• Cameron Mann as Brian Frazee (IMDb (film database))
• Matt Gomez Hidaka as Eric Garcia (IMDb (film database))
• Ari Aster appears uncredited as a Radio Journalist (Wikipedia (public encyclopedia))

What this means: the supporting roster is deep, with several performers taking single-scene roles. That suggests a sprawling, ensemble-driven narrative where even minor characters get distinct names and functions.

What did critics say about the Eddington film?

Early critical reception and themes

• Critics have described the film as Ari Aster’s “desperate call for decency” (Wikipedia (public encyclopedia)).
• Reviews are mixed, with praise for the director’s ambition but noting divisive elements (Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator)).

Is Eddington worth watching? Critics weigh in

“A standoff between a small-town sheriff and mayor sparks a powder keg as neighbor is pitted against neighbor.”

— Rotten Tomatoes plot summary

“Ari Aster’s ‘Eddington’ and his desperate call for decency”

— Review headline (Wikipedia)

The trade-off: early reactions suggest the film is provocative but not universally appealing. Those who enjoy Aster’s previous works (Hereditary, Midsommar) may find more to appreciate than casual viewers.

Why did Eddington flop?

Box office performance and industry context

• The film is listed among the biggest box office flops in movie history per IMDb (IMDb (film database)).
• Reasons for its underperformance include limited audience appeal and mixed critical response.

Possible reasons: niche appeal, divisive reception

• The satirical neo-Western genre has a smaller built-in audience than mainstream horror or comedy.
• Aster’s previous films have been polarizing; Eddington continues that trend.
• Competition from other summer 2025 releases may have split viewer attention.

The catch: a director with a cult following can struggle to translate that into blockbuster numbers. For Phoenix and Pascal, the film may become a footnote in their careers rather than a highlight.

The 7 spec rows above capture the production data — but the table also reveals what’s missing: runtime, budget, and audience score. Those gaps hint at the secrecy still surrounding the project.

Timeline

• 2024 – Filming reported and cast announced (IMDb (film database))
• 2025 – Expected theatrical release on July 18, 2025 (Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator); A24 trailer (official studio channel))

“A standoff between a small-town sheriff and mayor sparks a powder keg as neighbor is pitted against neighbor.”

— Rotten Tomatoes plot summary

“Ari Aster’s ‘Eddington’ and his desperate call for decency”

— Review headline (Wikipedia)

The film’s ensemble is its strongest asset, but the mixed reception and box office flop suggest that even great actors can’t always save a divisive script. For the stars involved, Eddington may become a curiosity in their filmographies — a bold experiment that didn’t quite land with mainstream audiences. For the industry, it’s a reminder that director-driven auteur projects carry financial risk. For viewers, the choice is clear: if you value artistic ambition over crowd-pleasing polish, Eddington might be worth your time. If not, skip it and wait for the next A24 sensation.

Related coverage: Eddington Film – Plot, Cast, Release and Reviews fördjupar bilden av Eddington Film – Plot, Cast, Release and Reviews.

Frequently asked questions